The newly created service and spending variation index (SSVI) scoring system could challenge hospices’ compliance capabilities.
The new SSVI system was recently introduced in the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS) 2027 final hospice rule. The scoring system uses nine claims-based measures to evaluate different aspects of hospice utilization and non-hospice spending.
The new measures signal the potential for significant regulatory changes on the horizon, including an overhaul to the Medicare Hospice Benefit. This is according to Katie Wehri, vice president for regulatory affairs, quality and compliance at the National Alliance for Care at Home.
“It’s a clear message to hospice providers,” Wehri told Hospice News. “What about the payment structure needs to be changed to address all the issues with non-hospice spend and the gaps that we have in the hospice benefit? It’s a clear indicator that there is a push to modernize the hospice benefit, and there’s a push to hold hospices accountable to administering the benefit. They need to be aware of what other providers are serving to the patient.”
Breaking down the new measures
The “clear message” from the SSVI’s introduction is that hospices need strong care coordination with other providers to ensure compliance, Wehri stated.
The SSVI is designed to help patients and their families make informed decisions about hospice care. The new scoring system is also aimed at identifying providers requiring increased oversight and transparency.
Through the new system, hospices are evaluated on nine claims-based measures, which are calculated into an overall score between zero and 16. Hospices with a higher score may signal program integrity risks or inappropriate service utilization.
Providers should track non-hospice spending rates among their patients as a main area of compliance concern, according to Wehri. Compliance with the SSVI scoring system also involves hospices focusing on their patterns of live discharges and patient visits.
Some of the SSVI system’s metrics include:
- Eight separate thresholds to measure a provider’s degree of total non-hospice spending
- No provision of continuous home care
- No utilization of hospice general inpatient care (GIP)
- Percentage of routine home care visits provided in a nursing home or skilled nursing facility setting
- Percentage of live discharges with a hospice’s overall discharge rates
- Percentage of patients who return to the same hospice within seven days of a live discharge
Mounting fraud, compliance concerns
The SSVI scoring system has raised concerns across several legitimate hospice providers and industry stakeholder groups alike, Wehri stated.
CMS received comments on the 2027 final rule that the SSVI scoring system may result in compliance and regulatory burdens for providers. Among the industry concerns is that the SSVI may require hospices to make additional staff and technology investments. These investments may be insufficiently covered by the 2.3% payment increase included in the agency’s final rule.
The scoring system could bring substantial changes for hospices when it comes to billing review processes, as well as care coordination and transitions of care, according to Wehri. CMS introduced the new tool without clear explanation of what the SSVI system represents, she said.
A significant concern is that the SSVI tool requires hospices to track spending that is not submitted on their own billing claims, Wehri said. Hospices need to understand what services are being simultaneously provided to their patients by other healthcare providers. This requires a disciplined approach to care coordination, she indicated.
“There may be disagreement across the sector as to what exactly these thresholds should be,” Wehri said. “The SSVI is a huge statement for the industry. We have not felt the intensity of the expectation around non-hospice spend like we are feeling it now.”
CMS introduced the SSVI scoring system to better identify instances of Medicare fraud, waste and abuse amid program integrity issues percolating in the hospice space. The agency indicated in the final rule that the system will be used to better identify hospices that are “outliers” across many different utilization metrics of high-level spending.
Providers that score at the top or bottom 25% of overall hospice utilization and non-hospice spending face risks of greater regulatory oversight and enforcement.
“The SSVI is not the only tool that CMS will use for program integrity. They want a matrix approach for providers,” Wehri said.
The SSVI metric will be a “moving target,” and adjust around several variables, Wehri stated. Not only is the scoring system “heavily weighted” around non-hospice spending, the measures also do not sufficiently normalize for geographic location, organization size or patient acuity mix, she said.
The system’s measures may not be an accurate way of evaluating suspicious activity in the hospice space, Wehri Indicated.
“The SSVI data is not a real indicator of hospices that are fraudulent,” Wehri told Hospice News. “[The Alliance], as well as many other commenters, shared scenarios where folks had a lower SSVI score, yet they were revoked or suspended. There are plenty of examples to show that SSVI is not a good tool for identifying fraudsters or those hospices providing poor quality care.”

